In the realm of pop and country music, Taylor Swift is a name that needs no introduction. With a discography that spans multiple albums and countless chart-topping hits, she has captured the hearts of millions. However, even within her extensive catalog of songs, there are hidden gems that often go unnoticed, even among her dedicated fan base, the Swifties. A recent Reddit thread in the r/TaylorSwift community delved into this very topic, asking fans to share Taylor Swift songs that are so underrated they tend to be overlooked even by Swifties themselves.
The thread, initiated by a user named LeonBassGroove, sparked a lively discussion among fans. With over 2,000 comments, Swifties passionately shared their picks for the most underrated songs, ranging from “I Know Places” to “The Last Time” and “Afterglow.” The discussion revealed not just the songs that are often overshadowed by her mega-hits, but also the emotional and lyrical depth that these lesser-known tracks offer. Whether it’s the “heart-wrenching” nature of “The Last Time” or the “quiet but dignified sadness” in “Peace,” these songs hold a special place in the hearts of those who discover them.
1. “I Know Places”
The energy behind the 2nd ‘AND WE RUN’ is maybe my favorite moment on the album
Experiment626b
For me it’s right after that when she launches into the slow “bay-beeee I know places we won’t be found”. Ughhh. It’s such a banger.
mountain_rivers34
Why It’s Underrated
“I Know Places” is a track from Taylor Swift’s 2014 album “1989.” The song was written by Taylor Swift and Ryan Tedder and explores the theme of how external influences can ruin a relationship. It emphasizes the need for privacy to protect a fragile relationship. The song has not received as much attention as other hits from the album, making it a hidden gem.
Additional Information
“I Know Places” is a harmonious fusion of Taylor Swift’s lyrical prowess and the creative brilliance of Ryan Tedder, a partnership that births a sonic masterpiece. The song delves deep into the thematic landscape of relationships besieged by external forces, casting a spotlight on the fragility of love when exposed to prying eyes.
Swift’s lyrics serve as a tapestry of emotions, depicting a narrative of two souls seeking refuge from the invasive gaze of the world. Like two elusive creatures evading capture, the protagonists navigate a world that seeks to exploit and dismantle their love. It’s an exploration of vulnerability and the lengths one will traverse to safeguard the purity of a connection that transcends the mundane.
At its core, “I Know Places” encapsulates the notion that love is a treasure to be shielded, a sanctuary to be concealed from the judgmental eyes of society. Through its ethereal melodies and poignant verses, the song communicates the urgency of finding a haven where love can flourish unencumbered by the world’s scrutiny.
Taylor Swift’s candid revelation about the song’s inspiration offers a glimpse into its profound meaning. Swift describes “I Know Places” as an anthem for those relationships that thrive in secret, those connections that are fortified by discretion and a shared determination to protect what’s sacred.
The song’s resonance lies in its ability to capture the universal experience of safeguarding love against external pressures. It’s a testament to Swift’s capacity to translate intricate emotions into a musical tapestry that resonates with listeners.
While it may have not garnered the same spotlight as its chart-topping companions, “I Know Places” remains a hidden treasure within Swift’s discography, a hauntingly beautiful ode to love’s resilience.
2. “Peace”
I absolutely, from the bottom of my heart, adore this song. Asking for forgiveness for the fact that it’s just not always going to be easy, especially related to mental health like someone said below. It’s so hard to worry that your partner is not going to be able to handle everything about you.
This 1000%!!! “would it be enough if I could never give you peace” like UGH
Last-Injury-1924
Why It’s Underrated
“Peace” is a track from Taylor Swift’s 2020 album “Folklore.” The song is a departure from her usual pop-centric style, embracing a more indie-folk sound. It explores the complexities and uncertainties that come with being in a relationship, particularly when external factors and personal demons are at play. Despite its emotional depth and unique sound, it often gets overshadowed by other hits from the album.
Additional Information
“Peace” stands as a testament to Taylor Swift’s artistic evolution, as she ventures into the realm of indie-folk, diverging from her pop-centric roots. Amidst a landscape of musical exploration, the song beckons listeners to explore the uncharted territories of love where uncertainties and vulnerabilities intertwine.
The song’s melodies and Swift’s evocative lyrics coalesce into a poignant plea for acceptance and understanding. It speaks to the yearning for a love that’s resilient enough to withstand the storms of life. Swift’s vocals and the atmospheric production create an ambiance of vulnerability, as if inviting the audience into a shared emotional space.
“Peace” echoes the sentiment that love doesn’t exist in isolation from the complexities of reality. Instead, it’s a delicate equilibrium between devotion and the challenges that life imposes. Swift’s lyrics peel back the layers, revealing the internal struggles and external pressures that can strain even the strongest bonds.
Taylor Swift’s own reflection on the song highlights its depth. She describes “Peace” as a meditation on the intricacies of loving someone while navigating the turmoil of one’s own inner battles. It’s an ode to the desire to offer love despite harboring personal demons, an endeavor to provide solace while wrestling with the complexities of one’s own identity.
Despite its nuanced exploration of love’s complexities, “Peace” might not have garnered the same widespread attention as its counterparts within the album. However, its significance lies in its ability to resonate deeply with those who’ve treaded the challenging terrain of relationships marred by external factors and internal conflicts.
As you tread the lyrical pathways of “Peace,” you’re invited to a space where vulnerability is embraced, where the pursuit of love is both noble and intricate. Swift’s exploration of the human experience, painted with lyrical finesse, cements “Peace” as an introspective gem within her repertoire.
3. “Treacherous”
My favorite TS song! For me this is a song about self-sabotage and people pleasing and I relate to it a little too much… Can’t hate it though because the bridge sends me every time.
azulimarill
If you don’t get it yet, try just reading the lyrics. I genuinely can’t pick the best one. Every line is absolutely stunning
poisonprotist
Why It’s Underrated
“Treacherous” is a standout track from Taylor Swift’s critically acclaimed 2012 album, “Red.” While the album itself is a tour de force of emotional storytelling, “Treacherous” holds its own as a nuanced exploration of the vulnerabilities and uncertainties that come with embarking on a new relationship. Despite its intricate lyricism and emotional resonance, the song is often eclipsed by other chart-topping hits from the album, such as “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together” and “I Knew You Were Trouble.”
Additional Information
“Treacherous” transcends the realm of conventional love ballads, morphing into a profound exploration of the human heart’s fragile dance between caution and yearning. It is more than a song—it’s an auditory tapestry woven with the threads of intricate lyricism and palpable emotion.
Critics and listeners alike have recognized “Treacherous” for its lyrical sophistication, ranking it among Taylor Swift’s most eloquent compositions. It’s an eloquent tribute to the subtle complexities of emotional navigation, resonating with those who have stood on the cusp of pivotal relationships.
The song gracefully captures the essence of a delicate waltz between attraction and apprehension, mirroring the profound journey we undertake when diving into the unknown waters of love. Its verses are a canvas of internal battles, a lyrical mirroring of the human psyche grappling with the dual forces of caution and desire.
Amidst the bustling landscape of “Red,” marked by infectious pop anthems, “Treacherous” remains an understated gem—a song that beckons listeners to lean into their own vulnerabilities and embrace the uncertainties that make love an exhilarating yet treacherous voyage.
As you let the melodies of “Treacherous” envelop you, you’re invited to partake in the song’s emotional odyssey, a tale of treading the line between safety and surrender. Swift’s lyricism constructs a bridge between individual experiences and the universal sentiment of grappling with the enigmatic nature of romantic entanglement.
“Treacherous” doesn’t just delve into matters of the heart; it embarks on an exploration of the very essence of human connection. Its allure lies in its ability to transport listeners to that precipice where fear and hope entwine, inviting them to reflect on their own journeys of love and vulnerability.
4. “Evermore”
ugh yes. when i was shipwrecked, i thought of you in the cracks of light, i dreamed of you and i swear you were there… ARE YOU KIDDING.
Scared_Repeat_8387
Yes omg I maintain that this song is the prettiest her voice has ever sounded. It’s stunning.
Greeneyedgal13
Why It’s Underrated
“Evermore” is a poignant track from Taylor Swift’s ninth studio album of the same name, released in 2020. The song serves as the album’s closing number and features Justin Vernon of Bon Iver. Despite its emotional weight and the depth of its lyrics, “Evermore” often finds itself in the shadow of other more commercially successful tracks from the album, such as “Willow” and “No Body, No Crime.”
Additional Information
“Evermore” isn’t just a song; it’s an immersive journey through the intricacies of human experience—both its depths of despair and the radiant glimmers of hope. This composition stands as an opus of Swift’s songwriting prowess, expertly weaving together a mosaic of lyrical complexity and haunting melodies.
Lauded by critics and embraced by souls seeking solace, “Evermore” ventures into the heart of human resilience, offering a musical sanctuary for those traversing the labyrinth of emotions. As Taylor Swift’s vocals intertwine with the ethereal cadence of Justin Vernon, the song transcends its melodic form, becoming a vessel for catharsis and connection.
The final offering of the album, “Evermore” serves as an exclamation point to the emotional odyssey embarked upon by the entirety of the album. It encapsulates the essence of the album’s narrative, a journey through the maze of human sentiment, replete with the highs and lows that define our existence.
As Swift’s lyrics interlace with Vernon’s haunting timbre, “Evermore” paints a tableau of raw authenticity—an exploration of vulnerability, despair, and the indefatigable spark of hope that persists even in the darkest hours. The song’s evocative melodies and introspective verses lay bare the complexities of the human heart, inviting listeners to immerse themselves in the profound and the poignant.
“Evermore” stands as a testament to Taylor Swift’s musical evolution, as she deftly navigates the terrain of introspection and vulnerability. It is a masterful embodiment of her ability to translate emotion into art, transforming fleeting moments into timeless melodies.
In a symphony of sound and sentiment, “Evermore” stands tall as an underrated gem in Swift’s expansive repertoire. It beckons listeners to traverse its emotional landscapes, to confront their own fragility, and to emerge with renewed resilience, echoing the very essence of the human spirit itself.
5. “Afterglow”
THIS IS THE ONE. How this wasn’t the most talked about song on Lover baffles me
StatusNo1152
Listening to it right now and ran to comment. I was so sad it wasn’t my surprise song.
DoubleRainbowUnicorn
Why It’s Underrated
“Afterglow” is a track from Taylor Swift’s 2019 album “Lover,” an album that explores the multifaceted nature of love. While the album itself garnered significant attention with hits like “Lover” and “You Need To Calm Down,” “Afterglow” often finds itself in the background. This is surprising given its emotional depth and lyrical brilliance, which delve into the complexities of making amends and seeking forgiveness in a relationship.
Additional Information
“Afterglow” stands as a testament to Swift’s ability to capture the nuances of human emotion, particularly the vulnerability and humility that come with admitting one’s mistakes in a relationship. The song serves as an apology, but it’s more than just saying “I’m sorry.” It’s an acknowledgment of one’s own flaws and a plea for understanding and reconciliation.
The song’s title, “Afterglow,” metaphorically encapsulates the moment of clarity that often comes after a heated argument or a period of emotional turmoil. It’s that soft light that breaks through the clouds of misunderstanding, illuminating the path to reconciliation. Swift’s lyrics are a blend of regret and hope, capturing the essence of wanting to make things right: “Hey, it’s all me, in my head / I’m the one who burned us down / But it’s not what I meant / I’m sorry that I hurt you.”
Musically, the song features a blend of soft electronic beats and ethereal synths, creating an atmosphere that complements its emotional narrative. The production is subtle yet impactful, allowing Swift’s vocals and lyrics to take center stage.
In a discography filled with tales of love, heartbreak, and everything in between, “Afterglow” shines as an underrated masterpiece that tackles the often overlooked aspects of love—accountability and forgiveness. It may not have received the commercial acclaim of other tracks on the “Lover” album, but its emotional resonance makes it a hidden gem worth discovering.
6. “Breathe”
It’s one of the first T Swift sings I fell in love with! I can’t tell you how many times I have listened to/sung along to this song. It’s just beautiful.
jean_nina_clara
Agree. Underrated as hell even among the swifties. I mean, you never hear anyone say anything about it. I think it’s pretty and yes, the lyrics flow very well
lindsaylove22
Why It’s Underrated
“Breathe” is a standout track from Taylor Swift’s sophomore album, “Fearless,” which was released in 2008. What sets this song apart within Swift’s discography is its poignant exploration of the dissolution of a close friendship, a theme that diverges from her more frequent focus on romantic relationships. Despite its remarkable emotional depth and relatability, “Breathe” often finds itself overshadowed by the commercial success of other hits from the same album.
Additional Information
Co-written by Taylor Swift and Colbie Caillat, “Breathe” delves into the emotional aftermath of losing a cherished friend. Rather than centering on a romantic breakup, the song navigates the complex feelings that arise when a deep friendship comes to an end. Swift’s lyrics adeptly capture the toll that growing apart can take on both parties involved. The melody and arrangement evoke a sense of wistfulness, underscoring the theme of change and separation.
Through its heartfelt lyrics and a melody that lingers in the mind, “Breathe” encapsulates the universal experience of outgrowing a once-close connection. Its capacity to resonate with listeners who have experienced the loss of a friendship adds to its emotional resonance. In the grand tapestry of “Fearless,” “Breathe” stands as a reminder that Swift’s storytelling prowess extends beyond romantic narratives, making it an underrated gem deserving of greater recognition.
7. “State of Grace”
I WAS ABOUT TO SAY 🥹 jesus that song is just top tier, I can’t decide original v acoustic because it’s just SO GOOD 🙌🏻
adrianamiron
One of my fav songs! so criminally underrated.
koala_loves_penguin
Why It’s Underrated
“State of Grace” holds the distinction of being the opening track on Taylor Swift’s 2012 album “Red.” Despite its pivotal role in setting the tone for the entire album, it often finds itself in the shadows of other more widely recognized hits from the same release.
Additional Information
With profound lyrical depth and musical artistry, “State of Grace” is a testament to Swift’s songwriting prowess. It has been hailed as one of Swift’s most finely crafted compositions. The song captures the essence of entering a relationship filled with excitement, hope, and the vulnerability of the unknown. Yet, this very essence that makes the song so powerful might be the reason it sometimes goes unnoticed.
The song’s balance between vulnerability and resilience is mirrored in its musical arrangement, which seamlessly blends elements of rock and pop. The soaring chorus and anthemic melodies reflect the soaring emotions of the song’s themes. In the context of an album that traverses the spectrum of emotions, “State of Grace” introduces a layer of complex yearning and fervent optimism.
While it might not have enjoyed the same commercial spotlight as some of its counterparts, “State of Grace” remains a hidden treasure within Taylor Swift’s discography. Its exploration of love’s intricate nuances, set against a backdrop of musical sophistication, positions it as an underrated gem that deserves to shine brighter.
8. “The Way I Loved You”
The Other Side of the Door has been one of my favs from Fearless since the day that Fearless Platinum Edition first came out. I’m glad it’s gotten more attention since Fearless TV because the outro is absolutely one of the best moments in Taylor’s entire discography.
(And The Way I Loved You is SO good. Altered my brain chemistry in middle school.)
otherwisesad
Both of these are phenomenal songs! The Way I Loved You was on an endless loop for a lot of my senior year. And I will die of no oxygen before I take a breath before it is time to in the outro of The Other Side of the Door.
samthebookdragon
Why It’s Underrated
“The Way I Loved You” is a track from Taylor Swift’s second studio album, “Fearless,” released in 2008. The song explores the complexities of being in a relationship with a “perfect” guy but missing the emotional roller coaster of a previous, more complicated relationship. Despite its emotional depth and relatability, it often gets overshadowed by other hits from the album.
Additional Information
With an emotional depth that resonates with many, “The Way I Loved You” delves into the intricate nuances of relationships. It uniquely navigates the emotional journey of being in a seemingly ideal relationship that lacks the intense emotional whirlwind of a past, more tumultuous one.
The song artfully captures the essence of conflicting emotions that arise when comparing the stability of a current relationship with the roller coaster of feelings experienced in the past. It unearths the yearning for the highs and lows that once defined love, even while being in a relationship that appears faultlessly composed.
Musically, the song’s arrangement mirrors its thematic duality, alternating between moments of tender introspection and bursts of passionate crescendos. Swift’s emotive vocals infuse every lyric with a raw authenticity that drives home the song’s emotional complexity.
While it may not have claimed the spotlight as some of its chart-topping counterparts, “The Way I Loved You” remains a hidden gem that captures the intricacies of love in its various forms. Its ability to navigate the tangled web of emotions within a seemingly perfect relationship sets it apart as an underrated masterpiece within Swift’s repertoire.
9. “Happiness”
My favorite Taylor Swift song of all time, edging out Style because the lyrics are literally perfect and because I’ve lived this story irl and Happiness helped me gain the closure I felt I was lacking.
good_hard_fun
I was so sleeping on that song then like a week ago I was listening to some of evermore and was really listening to the lyrics and “I can’t make this go away by making you a villain” and “ no one teaches you what to do when a good man hurts you and you know you hurt him too”. Chills. Especially right now those lyrics really hit me hard.
MasterOfRNoSleep
Why It’s Underrated
“Happiness” is a track from Taylor Swift’s ninth studio album, “Evermore,” released in 2020. Despite its title, the song is fundamentally a breakup song that captures post-split emotions. It’s a song that goes beyond the typical breakup narrative to explore the journey of finding happiness after the relationship has ended.
Additional Information
Beneath its deceptively simple title, “Happiness” ventures into the realm of post-breakup emotions with a depth that sets it apart. Beyond the confines of the conventional breakup narrative, the song delves into the complex journey of discovering happiness after the shards of a relationship have settled.
“Happiness” stands as a testament to the profound and often uncharted emotions that follow the end of a romantic chapter. It transcends the boundaries of heartbreak to explore the intricate path of transitioning from the ache of loss to the serene acceptance of another’s happiness.
Critics and fans alike have speculated that the song draws inspiration from F. Scott Fitzgerald’s literary masterpiece, “The Great Gatsby.” Echoes of the classic resonate throughout, with allusions that add layers of meaning to Swift’s introspective verses. As the narrative unfolds, the listener is immersed in a tapestry of emotions, each thread woven with care and vulnerability.
With its subtle yet masterful composition, “Happiness” captures the nuances of growth and healing, inviting listeners to embark on a journey of self-discovery. While it may have remained in the shadows, its profound resonance remains an unspoken testament to the depth of Taylor Swift’s artistry.
10. “Dancing With Our Hands Tied”
Absolutely love this song. I don’t care whatever song she plays at the concert I plan to go to, but I will be a little extra happy if she would play this one.
So_inadequate
FOR REALLLLLLLL. I cannot believe how many people overlook this song??? The way it builds up to the breakdown and the « I had a bad feeling » ‘s is so top tier.
fatdog093
Why It’s Underrated
“Dancing With Our Hands Tied” is a track from Taylor Swift’s 2017 album “Reputation.” The song is a blend of electropop and synth-pop, and it explores the complexities of a relationship that feels doomed from the start. Despite its emotional depth and intricate production, it often gets overshadowed by other hits from the album.
Additional Information
“Dancing With Our Hands Tied” immerses listeners in a symphony of electropop and synth-pop elements, crafting an auditory tapestry that mirrors the intricacies of its lyrical narrative. In the midst of catchy melodies and pulsating rhythms, the song explores the poignant complexities of a relationship that seems destined for heartache from its very inception.
The song’s title itself encapsulates the paradoxical nature of the relationship it portrays. Like dancers bound by invisible strings, the protagonists sway to a passionate rhythm while weighed down by the looming specter of uncertainty. This duality of emotions is woven intricately into the very fabric of the song, inviting listeners to navigate the intricacies of love that thrives despite the odds.
Within the labyrinth of “Dancing With Our Hands Tied,” Swift crafts a narrative that captures the essence of navigating a relationship akin to treading a tightrope. Passion and vulnerability intersect, creating a poignant portrait of love in its most fragile yet fervent form. As the lyrics unfurl, they mirror the emotional tightrope walk that the protagonists undertake, a dance of conflicting emotions illuminated by Swift’s lyrical prowess.
The song’s allure lies in its ability to evoke an empathetic resonance, allowing listeners to connect with the universal experience of love that defies obstacles. It’s a testament to Swift’s artistry that she encapsulates the nuances of human relationships within the confines of a song, and “Dancing With Our Hands Tied” stands as a testament to her lyrical and sonic range.
While it may have dwelled in the shadows of more illustrious tracks, “Dancing With Our Hands Tied” remains a testament to the depth of emotion that Swift can evoke through her music.